Laman

Kamis, 17 Maret 2011

Review of "But The One On The Right" By Dorothy Parker

            This short story tells about a woman who got a big exciting through a man on her right. The event happens in the restaurant during being a dinner between Mrs. Parker and a man on her left. There are three characters are mentioned in this story. Mrs. Parker is a narrator which is marked by the first monologue in the narration, “I knew it” said her. The narrator always shows of herself because she has a dialogue with the man on her left.

The man sits next to Mrs. Parker with a bored talking. She feels boring cause of sitting with a dull man. Fortunately she could cover her bad mood by talking the man on her right. All of she can see is only his shoulder. It seems a nice shoulder for Mrs. Parker. The narrator used a monologue as sarcasm toward the man on her left. She made a dialogue with the man by talking the other man, who sits next to a woman on the right of.

Sarcasm: Mrs. Parker always focused on her right though only the shoulder appeared. She started talking him when every foods had came over his table. The narrator asks about everything had happened to the man on her right through man on her left. All of dialogue which refers to her right made a death sentences for the man on her left. The man likes a fish and she does too (Mrs. Parker). But there’s something makes her wonder to like in that man. The man has been engaged in that event. That’s at all, the way to resist the man’s offer, the man who is on her left. Then Mrs. Parker met him in the party nightly. In the ending story Mrs. Parker got out the party with the man on her right.   

This story has a similarity with “Very Short Story” in the ending of the story, based on my point of view. According to the narration of this story, Luz has a patient who has a job out of the country. The patient is an army who stay in the hospital. He really needed hospitality from Luz as a nurse. Both of them love each others. Luz wished that she can be married with him. So he agreed to marry her after the armistice. He would be back absolutely. Unfortunately Luz never received a massage. Luz wrote a later for him but there’s no an answer to the letter to Chicago. Finally the man didn’t marry her; he certainly had married another woman.

The narration in “Very short story” is similar to the ending of both stories. The point in this story “But The One On The Right” is all of the possibilities will absolutely happen if we have a master plan before step to decision and judgment. And then the man whom Mrs. Parker loves is on her right not on her left.